I am fairly new to Paradox Studio's Hearts of Iron 3 which is a lot overwhelming than CK2, EU 4 or Victoria for me. So it might just be something silly on my part but here goes:
For context, I launched an invasion of Germany in a Two-Pronged attack from East and West. Western Divisions were supposed to break German Defenders along the Danish Peninsula and Follow the Coast to East. While Eastern Force was going to land at Konigsburg, Prussia and advance along the coast to West while annihilating opposition and capturing coastal belt. Both Forces were supposed to meet at Rostock in Pomerania region.
The Western attack failed and units were bogged down at Danish-German border, still trying to overpower the numerous hordes of Wehrmacht. (But that's okay since after taking Kiel with Eastern Force, I will be able to take the Germans on Danish border in rear and flanks. I'd be on Risk of being flanked myself but I don't see any such threat looming as other available units of Wehrmacht are being tied down by other Allied forces in France and Low countries). The Eastern Sea-borne force met with success and achieved its targets as far as Danzig since most of regional German forces were defending against Western force. Now the Eastern attack has stalled because my units have run out of supplies in Prussia and they are in a very vulnerable position there. I am trying to keep the Germans busy in Kiel & Leck (Western Side Force) to keep them off my starving troops in East but I don't know how long will they last.
Prior to launching the invasion, I destroyed almost all resources in Prussia with strategic bombing campaign lasting for weeks so that can be a factor in low supply.
Resources I have at hands for supply and escort duties: Meek mill dreams and nightmares zip.
- Transport Ships: 12
- Airborne Transport Airplanes: 12-14
- Two strong flotillas (Mixed forces of Heavy Cruisers, Light Cruisers and Destroyers) guarding the entry into Danish waters and Baltic Sea in General.
- 8 Wings of Interceptors and MRFs (Gloster Gauntlets and Spitfires) providing aerial umbrella.
- Ample resources in terms of Supply and fuel.
Despite having such superiority, I don't know how do I get supplies transported to my men.
Hearts Of Iron 4 Wiki
My order of battle is:
Now my understanding was that main HQ can supply troops as far as 2000 KM. Konigsburg is only 626 KM from Copenghagen which is why I undertook the invasion in the first place . What seems to be the problem?
Then I assumed maybe if I gained superiority of Baltic sea, that would open sealanes to my forces. So I intercepted the German fleet, gave battle, won and what remained of German Baltic fleet is currently hiding in Kiel which is constantly under port strikes from my tactical bombers. (I don't think any German naval units managed to make it across the sound and to safety of Wilhelmshaven. Either way, I have Kiel invested with a flottila in case the Germans decide to get out of the port and a submarine patrolling from Wilhelmshaven to Dutch Coast).
It never worked.
Failing to get automatic supply after I had gained control of Baltic sea as I assumed, I turned to other options. When I try to use Naval Transports to act as supply vassals, they don't get an option to supply or base in occupied territories even though I have built naval bases there.
Then I tried to use Aerial assets and they don't get any option either. All options are greyed out.
What else can I do to resupply the stranded divisions? Or am I doing something wrong in methods I have already tried?
UPDATEAfter losing the Eastern Force to low supplies, I raised another army and augmented Western Force with it. They broke through successfully and even after expanding southwards, I haven't yet faced low supply issue. Which makes me think, Is land connection between your HQ and forces needed for supply?
NSNoob
NSNoobNSNoob
1 Answer
Use the supply map mode. You want provinces to be green or blue (green = in supply, blue = generating surplus)
Supply calculation is a bit obtuse in HoI3. It is not really clear how it is calculated from a first look. There is an intrinsic system of depots, and then you need unbroken lines between those and the provinces supplied by them. Look at the supply map mode, and click on a province, to see what source it draws it supply from.
An interesting side note is that supplies stacked in a province (unused supplies) will be kept, until next day shift, where it will be sent back to the initial depot (surplus supplies) meaning you may use this time, to move units to the province and still have enough supply.
As for how the unit is supplied, it is from the province it is standing in. This means it will trace back, in an unbroken line, towards the listed 'depot' through all connected provinces, so it 'bubbles' up from the central, to your unit. The supply movement rate is one province per day.
This is then modified by the infrastructure levels in the provinces along the path.
So to make sure your units are still in supply, make sure they have unbroken paths of supply back to the depot (using the supply map), then make sure to upgrade infrastructure at key points in that link, to get bonus. Never allow the link to the listed depot be broken, as that would put your units out of supply.
Also, turn on auto-convoys as it helps. For naval supply to work, you need an unbroken connection from the desgnated depot, to a port, then from that port, to an open land route to your units (unless they are actually IN the province that has a port).
So check your supply map, to see where the problems lie, it makes it a lot easier to overview where your supply is cut, and where it chokes.
Richard TyregrimRichard Tyregrim
Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged hearts-of-iron-3 or ask your own question.
Posted by2 years ago
Archived
Background: I'm playing a game as Japan where I puppeted China. I am setting up a line of defense against Russia and Mongolia while I focus on uniting my Asian brothers and sisters under a common cause. To supply my divisions defending the Russian border, their supply leaves my Tokyo and ships out of Okinawa with a naval base level 10. I have a naval base level 5 in Korea.
Promblem: Out of Okinawa, the supply lines are being routed through a Chinese port that has a level 3 naval base and then travelling up through China into Korea to supply my line across the Russian Boarder. The level three naval base is showing as a bottle neck.
Question: Considering I can't upgrade China's ports or other infrastructure, is there a way to re-route the supply line to just go from the Japanese islands and into the level 5 port in Korea where I can control my supply lines with infrastructure upgrades? It seems awfully silly to ship supplies clear down to Shanghai to supply troops in Korea.
6 comments
Have you ever looked at a map and experienced an almost carnal rush of admiration? Then you've come to the right grand strategy PC videogame preview, for Hearts of Iron 4 has an excellent world map that depicts not only the movement of troops, but the vast logistical networks that support them. Enough games have tackled the close, tactical tit-for-tat of ground combat, this is a game about the industry, business and politics of war.
Hearts of Iron 4, like its predecessors, is set during World War 2, and runs on an advanced version of Crusader King 2's Clausewitz engine. Time trickles away at a gradual pace, but can be paused to issue complex orders. You take charge of the military infrastructure of a nation of your choice, and manage their war effort by tweaking interlocking layers of research, production, politics and, of course, troop movement.
You want to build a tank in Hearts of Iron 4. You've researched the production processes you need to assemble some famous German armour: the Panzer IV. You choose how many factories to assign to the task, but production lines for new technology are inefficient—a dozen facilities may only produce three tanks a week. Over time, they'll become faster and more useful, but there's a teething period that makes any switch to upgraded tech painful.
This simple rule lets Paradox reflect vital differences between each nation's industrial setup. German engineering favoured separate, tailored designs for their war machines, and that hurt their ability to mass produce. If you want to tech up as the Germans in Hearts of Iron, the production system will put you in a similar bind. If you master the tech transition problem, you can tweak new naval and heavy armour designs to boost their resilience, firepower or speed, and apply further buffs through the political system. Senior political figures apply bonuses to their areas of expertise; elect Joe McBoat to a top job and you'll receive bonuses to your naval output.
You've got your tanks, but you've got to get them to your front lines, keep them oiled, and keep their crews fed. Open supply lines are vital. At sea, you can target trade routes to damage enemy supply. On land supply is represented by a heat-map overlay that calculates how well supplied each zone is based on enemy influence in nearby areas, and the proximity of big population centres. Big cities are now capable of supplying themselves, which might seem like a small update, but this allows Hearts of Iron 4 to model prolonged sieges like Stalingrad where encirclement and air superiority won't necessarily guarantee a quick win.
Air dominance is still important, of course. You send bombers on air raid sorties from select home bases, but you'll want to make sure they're well guarded by fighters. If you rob the enemy of their AA capability, you can strike at their production centres with impunity to gain a vital production advantage. You can capitalise on your enemy's production woes with smooth manufacturing processes of your own, which you can accentuate by striking deals with the major tech companies of the time to take advantage of their engine-building and materials expertise.
You defeat nations by taking victory points within their territory, tied to a nation's major cities and landmarks. It's important to pay attention to terrain as you plan attacks. Countries are split into provinces, themselves split into subsectors that contain plains, forests and rivers that affect troop movement. You give your orders by assigning units to a commanding officer, and then drawing their orders onto the map, itself a detailed sketch of the world rendered in muted greens and coffee-stain browns. It's Europe through a moody instagram filter.
These arrows represent combat plans. As you leave them in place, they'll grow in effectiveness to reflect the extra intelligence and planning work being administered by top brass. It's a risk, though. Successful enemy spywork will reveal your movement arrows to the enemy and give them chance to prepare. As you'll see in the screenshot above, weather changes the map significantly, and there are penalties for sending infantry marching through the wilderness during winter in Russia.
Hearts of Iron 4 is shaping up well. It's slick and clever, and while there's not much, visually, to the moment that troops clash, the point of conflict in HoI is an almost incidental result of a vast continent-wide engineering effort. It's a game about careful, detailed state organisation and top-level strategy. You pull arrows across the map with a push of the mouse, painting out your strategy with sweeping gestures that give physical form to the feelings of power and control that drive a good grand strategy game. I hope its systems are balanced enough to prop up that fantasy. We'll find out when it's released early next year.